Tuesday, June 08, 2010

Yoropen Pencil Review

Yoropen Pencil Review

Is it a…mechanical pencil?
yoropen pencil
Good question. Well, it’s a pencil so lets just put definitions to one side for the moment.

My Yoropen pencil certainly gathered more than its fair share of “What’s that?” type questions from my work colleagues whilst I was using it for this review. That strange shape really catches people’s eye. Yoropen’s are available in several different models and in ballpoint pen and pencil modes. My model is the Executive pencil - it’s fairly heavy in the hand, more than you might expect, and the balance is a bit top heavy.

The Yoropen Executive Pencil comes in a rather attractive and functional case, much like the small cases for compact reading glasses (not that I am familiar with those!) The case provides excellent protection for the pencil when it is not in use. The writing tip itself is protected by a screw on plastic cover. When the pencil is in use, the screw on cover can be screwed onto the top end of the body as an interesting looking extension.
yoropen executive pencil and case

Yoropen have won a bunch of design awards and claim three main benefits for their ergonomic design – finger support, visual space and adjustable grip. The offset Z tip design also allows the writing tip to be much more vertical to the paper whilst allowing the pencil to be held at a traditionally sloped angle.

yoropen pencil push point holder
The Yoropen pencil is what is frequently called a ‘push-point’ or ‘pop-a-point’ pencil. I remember that for a year or two back in my primary school days push-point pencils were all the rage because of their easy use as blow-guns or other types of weaponry. Just to explain this ‘push-point’ business, the lead is fixed in a small plastic casing which in turn is usually held inside a tube. When the lead has worn down you remove the whole casing and replace it with a new casing. That then leads to the question, “Are push-point pencils mechanical pencils?” It’s not really advancing the lead in anyway, it’s an entire replacement of the lead, so I tend to think they aren’t mechanical pencils…but have your say in the Poll in the sidebar. (The poll is now closed, results here)

So, the Yoropen has a triangular rubber grip, as you might expect from an ergonomic type writing instrument. The rubber has a small amount of give under finger pressure and is a reasonably grippy compound so overall the grip section does work.
yoropen grip

The grip is also twistable, so you can orientate it to suit. I imagine this might be of more use on the Yoropen pen (especially to left-handers) rather than the Yoropen Pencil. Twisting the grip takes a fair bit of effort so it is not something you would routinely change. The Z shape of the offset tip also creates a wide ‘end-stop’ for the grip which some folk may use as part of their grip.
yoropen pencil front section

But, and it’s a big but, that Z offset tip section and triangular grip means you cannot in any normal fashion rotate the pencil…so as your lead wears down you quickly get a chisel edge (or rather a square end since the lead is somewhat perpendicular to the paper) and you can’t rotate it…and because it’s a thick lead push-point pencil you quickly loose that fine tip and get into the thicker main body…you see where I’m heading. Basically Yoropen lays down graphite like an ordinary woodcase pencil or leadholder, but one that you cannot rotate to help keep a sharp point on. For me personally, I think the technical term is “Yurr??” That pretty much sums it up. In an effort to keep the lead sharp I often resorted to holding the Yoropen at some strange sideways angle or even ‘upside down’ when doing some lines or ticks, etc just to try and re-sharpen a bit of a point on the lead. The lead supplied in the push-points was fairly hard wearing - I would have guessed F or perhaps H grade although I believe Yoropen claim HB. In any event I think I got my moneys worth of letters out of each push-point…but it was fat lettering. “Uggg”.

Now for the bad stuff. The push-points have some small amount of wobble when seated on their holder spike. The offset tip is touted as improving vision so you can easily see what you are writing, but it makes it a little harder to intuitively position the lead precisely. So, combine that with lead wobble… some of you precision-obsessed readers out there will already be ramming your keyboard through the screen to try and blot out the horror. Oh, of course the lead is also rather noisy. I assume it’s a ceramic lead like in a woodcase pencil.

yoropen pencil pop a point bodyOnly one push-point cartridge is held on the writing tip at a time, but more are stored in the main body – 9 to be exact, giving a total of 10 overall. You push your used cartridge into the top and a new one is pushed out of the other end which you then stick on the holder post. If you push your used one into the top end fairly forcefully the new one often shoots out the other end in a rather childishly pleasing manner.

In closing then, if you are convinced that there is a proper pencil-to-paper angle for general pencil writing purposes and that angle is relatively vertical, then the Yoropen achieves that angle. However you then find yourself in the worst of both worlds – you can’t sharpen and can’t rotate. Sure, you could replace the pop-a-points at a ridiculous rate and thus maintain a constant sharp lead, but that just seems wrong to me. Yes the Yoropen grip may well be useful for some folk with dexterity problems, and yes the offset Z tip may improve vision, but that’s at the expense of accuracy. Here I go then, flying in the face of prestigious international design awards and a truckload of user testimonials. I imagine my opinion of the Yoropen ballpoint pens might well be different, and some folk with special grip needs may find the Yoropen pencil to their liking, but for the vast majority of us the Yoropen pencil just doesn’t cut the mustard and would not be a good choice.
• Best Points – it will attract other peoples attention!
• Not So Good Points – read the review!
• Price Range – Mid/High.
• Does this pencil make it into the Top 5? - No.

Dimensions – Length 142mm excl tip cover, grip zone 14mm each side of the triangle. Balance point about 75mm up from the tip.

15 comments:

Mark said...

I don't think it's supposed to be held so that the tip is vertical; I think it's meant to be held so that the offset 'nib' attachment is rotated 90 degrees from vertical, so that it can be used in much the same manner as oblique-nibbed dip pens are used for Copperplate script in calligraphy. You'd get slightly better wear on the point that way, though I can't imagine that it would be a pleasant writing experience. A ballpoint Yoropen held at the traditional oblique angle probably wouldn't even write at all, as the angle would be too shallow. Anyway, do a Google image search on 'oblique pen' and you'll see what I mean. Very interesting as always Dave,

Mark

Henrik said...

Thanks for a nice and brave review. I was looking forward to this - and you didn't disappoint. You have some very good points: the balance, the rotating, the lack of control and the hard leads.
Like some of the innovative designs we see, nobody seems to care much for the functionality – I guess the prices are won for the sculptural design and the “idea”.
Nice going Dave – another one you saved me from...
Regards
Henrik

Anonymous said...

Hi Dave,
great review!
This is the perfect gift for my dentist :D

Yoropen have a german site too:
http://www.yoropen.de/index.htm

which is driven by?
*drum roll*

..

Ecobra!
:D

-Arne
:)

2nd_astronaut said...

Arne, yes, the dentist was also my first (not so good) association with this pencil :-/

Dave, very helpful review. I saw the yoropen some time ago in the net (probably with the ecobra review) and considered buying one for curiosity, but the non-rotating issue spoils it. I don't like thick leads.

Anonymous said...

these are made for left handed people (trust me i am left handed) but i believe that they can be adjusted for right handers, but i cant get used to it so i dont really use it...

Lefty : )

Kiwi-d said...

Hello Mark
I understand what you mean, and it would be possible to hold the pencil in that manner, but I don't believe thats their intention. All the main illustrations show it held vertically. There's no significant mention or indication of holding sideways in the instructions with the pencil, or on their website that I could see. They do though show how you can "change the line thickness" by rotating as you have suggested, and as mentioned in the review I did do that in an attempt to keep some sort of point on the pencil, but as you say it does not create a nice writing experience, rather the opposite. Also holding at that oblique angle would quickly create a chisel point too and the same non-rotatable comments would then apply.

Just for the record, my Yoropen is several years old.

Arne and 2nd - your dental references are right. I hadn't thought of that.

Time Waster said...

Looks like a oblique dip pen setup

Sapphire said...

I suppose you could use emery paper on the point but would it be worth it?

Kiwi-d said...

Yes, you could sharpen on sandpaper, but that seems far too much effort to me.

Anonymous said...

Did it lend itself to different angles or movements vs. straight barreled pens? I'm always up for things that can change the overall ergonomical feel or even use as I draw with them. Like stumbling onto the bulletshaped W├Ârther leadholders that easily allow broadsiding (like with a crayon) the lead.
I can imagine that this might allow for a more freed up feel, holding it like a hammer swiping at the paper, not that it might be of much use, if only for fun and variation.

pe

Kiwi-d said...

Well holding it at different angles produces very different sensations because the Z shape tip wildy exaggerates things. Rotating it is almost like using a whole new pencil. I don't think most people would like that, although some might.

Kiwi-d said...

Just for the record, I would like to re-emphasise my statement, "I imagine my opinion of the Yoropen ballpoint pens might well be different".
Unfortunately I haven't tried a Yoropen BP but I would anticipate my opinion being far more favourable than that of the pencil.

Palimpsest said...

And they got awards for that?! The mind boggles. Thanks for the wonderful review.

Anonymous said...

i used this design as a kid when in the 5th, back in the 70's. HOW? the pencil would become so small that it would become impossible to hold. i would put the pencil in a divider, the one that was used for drawing circles, and i did not like it because i could not rotate it to keep the point sharp.
check this link - http://www.google.co.in/imgres?imgurl=http://www.diefenbacher.com/Pencil%2520compass.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.diefenbacher.com/layout.htm&usg=__gZ7Vz7_dw3aiycGDRt6nkpBBnro=&h=437&w=245&sz=10&hl=en&start=6&zoom=1&um=1&itbs=1&tbnid=oCJ-JomIA9ZVWM:&tbnh=126&tbnw=71&prev=/images%3Fq%3Dpicture%2Bof%2Bpencil%2Bcompass%2Bwith%2Bpencil%2Bin%2Bit%26um%3D1%26hl%3Den%26client%3Dopera%26sa%3DG%26rls%3Den%26channel%3Dsuggest%26tbs%3Disch:1&ei=nb4wTZrmJY3XcPnjzKYH - you get the idea.
sd

Tracey, Mango Hill, Queensland, Australia. said...

Yoropen was initially developed because the inventor's children had pronounced fine motor skill limitations and did not do well with traditional pencils.
Our Occupational Therapist recommended Yoropen for our autistic son who also has fine motor skill delays. He loves the Yoropen and, due to the ease of holding the Yoropen correctly, can now concentrate on the words and drawings he wants to make rather than concentrating solely on holding the pencil correctly.
The Yoropen has been designed for a specific market and, I believe, it has achieved what was set out to be achieved with great success.
That is not to say that I believe the Yoropen to be flawless. The erasers on the pencil are so incredibly flimsy that they are next to useless. We do not use these erasers as frustration potential is unlimited. We also go through the points very quickly as they do not remain sharp and trying to sharpen them is not easy. I also wish the Yoropen was not so expensive.